“WHY won’t you pierce children’s ears?”

This is a question I get asked a lot. And especially at the start of summer holidays. My reasons may differ from someone else’s – and there may be people reading this who do not think my reasons are valid… that isn’t for me to argue, it amounts to the same thing whether you agree with me or not (I won’t pierce your child’s ears).

If you’re seeking a competent and professional piercer that WILL pierce childrens (under 16) ears, drop me a message and I will sent personal reccomendations. Studio policies change, which is why I’m not posting details here.

But what I am seeing (and am glad to see) is the amount of people contacting me asking if I will do this, and when I won’t, they are saying “I’m really struggling to find somewhere that will do it”. There are reasons that more and more places are requesting higher ages for piercings (yes, even ear lobe piercing), and I hope that this blog will explain why.

I want to start by saying that at time of writing there is NO law for ear piercing in the United Kingdom. Any restriction is the result of a combination of a piercer’s insurance restraints and that piercer’s personal moral compass. In Wales, there is a law for 18+ on tongue, nipple and genital piercings – and in the rest of the UK the only law is 18+ for genital piercing. This is hopefully on the change, but only time will tell what happens.

What this means is that LEGALLY, someone could bring a baby to a piercer and have their nose, lip, eyebrow, whatever pierced and there would be NO LAW BROKEN – of course, an insurer wouldn’t cover it, and morally I would hope no piercer would do this (praying to the piercing deities that this is true!) and this then presents the question, if you are horrified at the thought of a parent presenting their perfect, precious baby in a studio and saying “I want to get their tongue pierced, it’ll look so cute!” why is it different because it’s their ears?

A tongue-in-cheek extrapolation of this argument: https://reductress.com/post/were-piercing-my-babys-tongue-heres-why/

Sure, there’s the age old “well we all had it done when we were kids and nothing bad happened” – but we could say this about a lot of things in the world, doesn’t mean they were right. Change cannot simply happen overnight in the absence of a change in the law, but it CAN happen over time, which is why things are on the change now.

Full disclosure: I used to offer select piercing services to under 16s. After an abusive confrontation in 2008 where I wouldn’t allow a stepmother (no parent present) to sign for her stepdaughter, I made the call to be 16+. I am not a parent, so I cannot say what I feel is right “as a parent”, everything in this blog is “as a piercer”. No one knows your child like you do, and any piercer offering this service will want your input to a degree, but ultimately, they will decide on whether or not to do the piercing based on speaking to your child. I think you would agree that this is fair? So this is where the issue with babies and toddlers comes in – they cannot ask for and understand this procedure to the level needed to be comfortable with it, despite having many parents speak to me saying “but s/he REALLY wants it done” and then when enquiring about the age of the child they say “s/he’s 3”.

Regular followers will know that I will advise strongly against gun piercings – yet by not offering piercings to under 16s, this looks a little hypocritical. I am aware of this. If the laws were clearer and there were set measures in place, I would feel very different, and would likely offer the service. Probably gonna cause waves with this, but I truly feel that ANY piercing (or indeed ANY UNECESSARY alteration to your body) should be 18+. Though I know that this will never be the case, so I would be happy to have a lower age BY LAW if it meant there was an actual law which would cover my back, with set restrictions on what requirements must be fufilled.

Something I do not (and will not) discuss in this blog is ‘culture’. Cultures around the world have infant’s ear piercing as a huge part of welcoming them to the world. Me agreeing or disagreeing with this is an irrelevant point, because it is not a ‘thing’ in MY culture. We could argue that there are many things which are cultural that we don’t agree with or understand when it is not our own culture being discussed, so I have purposely left out this discussion.

**throughout this blog, I will use the words ‘kids’, ‘little ones’, ‘children’ and ‘minors’. To clarify: this is referring to a person under the age of 16, and using the term ‘parent(s)’ to mean a biological parent, or legal guardian**

So, historic ‘normality’ aside, what are my reasons? I would love any piercers reading this to add theirs in a comment too!

I’m not great with kids.

Let’s start with a debateable one…. SOME piercers who pierce minors put on a show, they are chatty and entertain little ones and make the whole thing an incredible panto-esque show that is absolutely amazing to watch. I’m not like that, I can’t talk to kids and I just don’t feel I can keep a relaxing atmosphere. A lot of this is probably down to me struggling with other kids when I was a kid, but the reasons why are not important. I can’t communicate efficiently with children.

Getting ID from people is hard enough, without me needing 2 items.

Insurance/Environmental Heath Dept. require the parent AND child to show valid, in date, photo ID. When we consider that a child needs their own, official, form of ID… it gets complicated – passport, driver’s licence or provisional or proof of age card with the PASS hologram are accepted. The proof of age cards aren’t available to a person under 13, provisional licences are only available for someone at the age of 15 years and 9 months, so the only option remaining for the child is a passport. The parent must also show photo ID (same options). Most piercers also insist on a birth certificate too – as proof that the adult is the parent of the child, and the names MUST match – this is to prevent someone other than a parent consenting to the procedure BUT it also means that if there has been a name change (a parent remarrying, or a child’s surname changing) then it won’t match. This makes it very difficult to have appropriate ID, and needing 3 forms makes it even harder, especially when I often struggle to get ONE piece from people!

Mo’ ages mo’ insurance!

As we’ve covered, insurance is needed (side note – it is NOT a legal requirement!) and that insurance, like with cars, costs more if you need more cover. Piercing children requires a modified insurance policy, which of course costs more per year. Sure, I’m getting insurance ANYWAY so an extra cost is no biggie, but it’s something that has to be factored in, extra expense for me has to then be reflected in my pricing of the services I offer.

How do I decide what age to pierce from?

This would be something that an insurer would guide me on, but my ethics could be different. If an insurer would cover me from 7 years, and I only felt comfortable piercing from 10, then I’d pierce from 10. But similarly, if insurance would only cover from 14 or 15, I’d have to weigh up if it’s worth the extra cost and, for want of a better word, hassle, to be able to offer a service 2 years sooner than I already do.

Every child is different – while some are ready to make a decision about their own body at 7 or 8. Some are ready at 11 or 12, and we could argue that some people are in their late teens before they can make rational decisions about their body. Who can tell this? The child would know, but may be coerced by a parent. Parents know their child better than anyone else in the world – I would hope that a parent would not push their child into something, but at the same time, not deny their child the chance of self-expression. This is a HARD THING TO GET RIGHT! Call me cautious, but I feel it is better to wait a little longer with this kind of thing – not rushing into something that both the parent and child may feel was “too soon”.

Personally, all the other reasons aside, if I offered piercing on under 16s, I would feel comfortable working on a case-by-case basis with 10 as my minimum age for earlobes. Another point I will discuss later is the factor of people requesting OTHER piercings, not just earlobes.

The child is not giving their own consent.

Obviously, this is something I would discuss with the child, explaining what would happen, talking them through it, and if I got the inkling that they weren’t 100% on board, I wouldn’t do it. But it is the PARENT that ultimately signs their name and consents on behalf of the child.

Working on a young person of 11 or 12, you can ask them questions. You cannot do that with a baby or toddler. Taking away a child’s right to consent to what is done to their body (not just piercing, circumcision, FGM, child marriage – obviously MUCH MORE extreme but still an adult choosing what is “best” for the child without the child having any input) can affect them in later life. For an unnecessary thing to be done to them with no medical benefit, without their say-so its simply not – in my eyes – appropriate! Teaching children about consent and boundaries is very important – I don’t want to get too much of a ‘downer’ here, but we tell our children that they must say “NO!” if a stranger approaches them, if someone – anyone! – touches them in a way they do not want to or are uncomfortable with and that they have a right to choose what their body goes through. And there can be no double standards, you can’t tell a child this but then YOU force them to go along with something they have changed their mind (withdrawn consent) from.

It’s never happened to me, but I have piercer friends who have done ONE of the pair of earlobe piercings, and then the parent has instructed the piercer to continue – the child has said ‘no’ – and the parent then bullies the child into doing the other “you’ll look silly with just one!”, “you have been asking for weeks, and you’re getting it done NOW!”, “I won’t bring you back again!”, “[piercer] must think you are being very silly for not getting the other done!” – yes, I have heard accounts of all these being said.

A worrying account from a former [Canadian] employee stating that she was instructed to go with the PARENT’S request, not the child’s – once again, the parent is giving consent to the procedure to be carried out on their child, so unless the PARENT says “No”, legally this is not wrong.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-us-canada-47885948

It is unnecessary… and it hurts!

We’ve just touched on unnecessary – but to hammer it home, this is a thing done to a child at a young age and it is not necessary. People will post on facebook “oh no, I have to take the little one for their injections on Tuesday!” feeling awful that they are having something don’t that will HURT but will get their ears pierced without a second thought. Why? A vaccination is important, necessary and saves lives (antivax comments will be deleted, so don’t bother) – a piercing is not. In babies and toddlers, piercing is done to satiate the parent’s vanity – nothing more.

Small Parts…

Something not many parents consider is the earrings themselves – would you let a baby or toddler handle a pair of earrings? No. You would not. Why? Well, they are going straight in the littleun’s mouth and getting swallowed, aren’t they? They are a choking hazard. So why attach 2 of these potentially lethal items to the sides of their little heads? Small objects all present a choking hazard, and earrings are no different – if they were to come loose, and fall out, baby sees them, picks them up and as babies and small children explore their surroundings using their hands and tiny little mouths, that’s where they will end up. Toys often have warnings “not suitable for children under 3 years due to small parts” – why are earrings different?

THEY HAVE TO TAKE THEM OUT FOR SCHOOL!!!

Any child of school age will have to remove their piercing(s) for school – sure, maybe they are allowed a small plain stud in each earlobe – but they have to come out for PE. Many schools simply do not allow piercings or any description. Honestly, I disagree with this. Kids have 5 years at secondary school where they can – within reason – do whatever they want to express themselves. If a child under 16 wants to be pierced, and the parent is allowing it, then the school should respect the PARENT’s decision. But that’s not the way it is.

However, the flip side of this – PIERCINGS TAKE LONGER THAN 6 WEEKS TO HEAL!!!! With some exceptions (tongue, septum – both of which are usually 4-6 weeks) piercings need longer to heal than the child will be out of school. The ‘6 weeks’ rubbish is only stated so parents will allow it to happen. And please don’t get me started on the unicorn piss 3-week-healing-solution that certain retailers will sell you for an extra tenner. If there is a ‘better’ aftercare product, why not only sell that one? (spoiler – neither the ‘regular’ or ‘3 week healing’ stuff is worth the money – sterile saline is the only thing you should be putting on piercings). This company is all about money – they do not care if your piercing heals or not, because they have your money! The ‘3-week’ stuff is essentially watered down (heavily watered down) bleach. I would love to know the difference in ingredients between the 2 different solutions to see what the magic ingredient is in the ‘3 week’ stuff.

Kids Grow.

I won’t be winning any nobel prizes for pointing this out, but when we are born, our eyes are the same size as the day we meet our maker – but our ears, nose and mouth (i.e. the things we pierce!) will grow, change shape and develop throughout our lives – mostly during growth spurts! I see soooo many people who have had a piercing done as a small child, and it is not in the wrong place due to the tissue around it expanding and developing.

Kids cannot take care of a wound.

Sure, maybe some can. But for the most part, leaving a child in charge of caring for an open wound is a bad idea. In most cases the parent will, of course, assist with the cleaning and care – as it is their signature on the form, if we want to be nit-picky, the piercing is THEIR responsibility (not the child’s) but kids will fiddle with and pull on their piercings – they will move the jewellery around through the piercing channel, not wash their hands, pick at any scabbing/dry skin…. In short, think about this as exactly what it is – a small puncture wound. Would you let your child look after that if it were on their arm or leg? Probably not.

Where does it end?

So, if I were to offer piercings for under 16s – what piercing locations would I offer? Sure, earlobes are the focus of this blog, but as long as I have been in the industry, I have seen people given an inch and they take a mile. If I offer earlobes, then the question will be “WHY won’t you do her helix?” “WHY won’t you do a navel?” “he already has 2 earlobe piercings on each side, WHY won’t you add a third?”. Offering one service opens a can of worms on what I will and won’t do – and people will lie and misrepresent themselves to get what they want, making me look like a fool.

So those are my reasons… If you would like to ask about something discussed, please post below. If you think I’ve missed something out, or have a counter-argument for anything, please let me know! I will add to this blog as needed. And I’d LOVE to hear from other piercers and parents about this one!

As I mentioned at the start – I feel that ALL piercing procedures should be 18+ – many reasons for this, the main one being that then no one would have to lie about anything. People would be upfront and things could be discussed. But reversing each of the points made above, this is why I feel piercings should come with higher age restrictions:

I feel I can communicate more effectively with adults.

Most people would have at least one form of photo ID by the time they are in their mid/late teens.

My insurance costs would be minimal (I still protest to myself that this ISN’T a real reason, mentioning it to be thorough).

Deciding what age to pierce from means I have a clear boundary.

The person would be giving their own consent

It’s still unnecessary, but at least the piercee is going into this of their own free will

Small parts are still small – but less of a choking hazard

Generally, any educational institute catering for people of 16 or older couldn’t give two hoots if they have piercings. Still the issue with jobs – that’s a whole other blog though!

Growing – all done!

Having an age limit also means having limitless possibilities when you reach that age.

What can we do about it?

Honestly? Not a lot. We can start petitions, make noise, DEMAND a law – but ultimately this isn’t something we can argue with the top about – we need to start at the bottom. Speak to your local environmental health department at the council. Sign (and start!) petitions on the .gov website. Share information – like this blog – to make people take notice. No minds will ever be changed with noise – lay out facts in a calm and concise way, use logic instead of tradition and slowly, minds will change. But keep your little corner of the world as safe as you can, and it will spread!

If you need more convincing – look at these pics and tell me if ANY of these children look like they are comfortable with the situation? (These were all from google) THESE PICS MAY BE DISTRESSING TO SOME PEOPLE!!! – Pics taken from google (public domain).

Thanks for reading!